Showing posts with label community. Show all posts
Showing posts with label community. Show all posts

Thursday, September 10, 2009

A newspaper business model that's working

We make community news free and have watched profits soar.

By Dan McDonough Jr. and Alan Bauer

It's widely reported – and has become generally accepted – that the newspaper model is either dying or already dead, when, in fact, thousands of newspapers across the country are doing quite well. Thousands of newspapers deliver for their readers and advertisers every day. Thousands of newspapers are positioned to embrace – not be destroyed by – emerging technology.
But we don't get to read much about those newspapers. Sure it's news when giant corporations crash and burn and lives are disrupted. Stories that report on incompetent leaders who, ironically, receive outlandish compensation are widely read. Documenting the downfall of powerful entities, whether they are governments or businesses, is a legitimate pursuit. But, as any respectable journalist knows, when you tell only half the story, the story is incomplete – or just plain wrong.
In this instance, the half that receives little to no attention from big media involves the men and women in the newspaper industry who write the stories, sell the ads, print and deliver the papers and update the websites every day, without fail, for media companies that are far from dead.
The National Newspaper Association (NNA) last month reported on a study that showed community newspapers were far less affected by the challenging economy than the industry in general (or the economy in general, for that matter). The Suburban Newspapers of America and NNA's reporting group showed 2008 fourth-quarter advertising revenue of $428.7 million, only a 6.6 percent decline from the same quarter in 2007. The Glennco Consulting Group estimate was much worse, however, for the overall newspaper industry. There it showed decline in fourth-quarter advertising expenditures of 21 percent, according to the NNA.
So while advertisers cut their spending by 21 percent across the industry, the impact to community newspapers was less than 7 percent.
In addition, 26 percent of the SNA/NNA reporting group launched new products in 2008. Indeed, many community newspaper companies are growing.
The fact is that gains among progressive community newspaper companies are offsetting a large part of the massive losses being suffered by the staid, big newspaper companies.
"Community newspapers certainly are not immune to the economic downturn that is affecting all businesses, but, as the primary and sometimes sole provider of local news in a community, they remain strong and viable," NNA president John Stevenson said in the article.
These "strong and viable" companies recognized and adapted to the changing economy in a way that larger newspapers – for the most part – are not. They adapted to evolving reader habits and emerging business models. They abandoned the traditional, head-in-the-sand mentality of denial and exploited the opportunities presented by their often larger, but undeniably obsolete, brethren.
At Elauwit Media, we learned long ago that people don't want to "pay" for their news anymore.
We know that, for advertising to be effective, people have to actually see the ads. Our business model and philosophy of making sure "Everybody Gets It. Everybody Reads It." pushes us to bring local news not found elsewhere to everybody who has an address in town. It fills a very specific need for our readers and it works so well that, for the past two years, we have been listed among South Jersey's 10 fastest-growing privately held companies. We've gone from a start-up in 2004 with $100,000 in revenue to a thriving company with revenues in excess of $2.4 million in 2008.
That's certainly not the story we're hearing about newspaper companies today. But that's the story of so many of us smaller newspaper companies that have adapted to the changes in the market.
This success is no great mystery – it's the American way. Ingenuity, creativity, and the entrepreneurial spirit always have been rewarded. The newspaper companies that have altered circulation methods and policies, have focused their content and developed news delivery methods to fit today's audience and advertisers are thriving. They found new streams of revenue and ways to reduce costs that didn't eviscerate their core products.
In other words, they ran their businesses the way businesses ought to be run. For instance, huge regional daily newspapers would do better to stop requiring people to subscribe and instead deliver the paper to everybody in their target demographic (the market that key advertisers want to reach). If big newspapers would charge the advertisers, not the readers, they could still turn things around. That would be a bold way to evolve. It is highly doubtful they'll do that. We did.
So as the giant media conglomerates continue to watch their kingdoms crumble, and the self-styled scribes of truth chronicle their every misstep and blunder, the rest of us will continue to vacuum up their former readers and advertisers. We'll continue to grow. We'll continue to adapt. We'll continue to profit. And we'll do it all while upholding the standards of journalism that make newspapers so important. And therein lies the future of newspapers – one that's not so gloomy for everyone.

Source: csmonitor.com

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Use social media to verify user-generated content, says Reuters global community editor

"ALMOST all your contributors will have some kind of online footprint," Mark Jones, the global community editor of Reuters, told the participants of a blogging conference on Monday morning .
This 'footprint' could be used to verify the agenda and background of the contributors of user-generated content (UGC), said Jones.
"We have some fairly well-established instincts now," Jones said in the opening panel for the Voices Online event.
"[We're] looking at their blog, their Twitter. This is one overlooked benefit of social media."
In a panel discussing state of the art technology, Jones and fellow panellists discussed questions arising from using UGC.
Turi Munthe, founder and CEO of Demotix, the citizen media website, described how the doctoring of Reuters' photographs from Lebanon in 2006 was brought to light because 'bloggers started getting involved in the process'.
Jones said Reuters treats all citizen contributions as freelance content and, if it is suitable for syndication, the organisation agrees deals with photographers before releasing material.
"We [Reuters] pre-moderate everything - we are very conservative in that respect," he said. The 'experienced' picture editor looks at everything, he added.
Munthe, however, said Demotix is far less conservative and is focused on making a 'concerted effort' to push the onus of responsibility back onto the users.
It is the responsibility of fellow users to highlight issues and help with verification of material, he said.

Source: journalism.co.uk

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Does It Matter When a Newspaper Closes?

By Bob Davis
With newspaper journalism looking more and more shaky, the question arises: Does it really matter to a community if a newspaper folds?
Princeton economist Sam Schulhofer-Wohl and a Princeton undergraduate research assistant, Miguel Garrido, tried to figure that out by looking at the effects of the closure of the Cincinnati Post at the end of 2007. Though the Post had a circulation of just 27,000, compared to the Cincinnati Enquirer’s 200,000, the Post was especially strong in the suburbs of northern Kentucky. In 48 communities there, the Post accounted for about 80% of the combined local news coverage of the two newspapers, the researchers estimate.
The researchers compared local elections in those suburbs during the presidential election years of 2004 and 2008 – the latter being after the Post folded. The results: voter turnout was reduced in 2008 by between 2 and 8 percentage points in the towns that Post covered most heavily, compared to towns where the Post wasn’t as dominant.
Similarly, the probability of an incumbent winning rose by between 8 and 19 percentage points in towns where the Post was strong compared to those where it was weak, while the number of people running for office dropped by between 2 and 14 candidates in 2008 for every 100 seats up for election in Post-dominated towns.
Of course, many other factors could be at play, say the researchers who label their work “statistically imprecise.” By comparing outcomes in communities where the Post was weak – and thus its closing wouldn’t be expected to have much effect – with communities where the Post was strong, they tried to reduce the likelihood of chance.
“If voter turnout, a broad choice of candidates and accountability for incumbents are important to democracy, we side with those who lament newspapers’ decline,” the authors write.
As a former newspaper reporter for the E.W. Scripps Co. chain, which also owned the Post, Mr. Schulhofer-Wohl says he was especially interested in research – and “relieved” at the outcome. Why did he change profession? “Journalism is really fun,” the 32-year-old economist says, “but I wanted a less chaotic lifestyle.”

Source: WSJ Blogs

This Way Out: How Journalism Can Reclaim Its Place in the World

SO newspapers are shuttering by the dozens and journalism students are fleeing news agencies for higher--and higher--paying ground. Does that mean the profession should throw in the carpet? Hardly.
A lot has been said of what's going wrong in the journalism profession these days. Newspapers are declining, advertisers are refusing to buy ad space in print, and twenty and thirtysomethings are getting more of their news from online resources than dead trees. It's all added up to a witch's brew of mass layoffs that has many veterans--and more than a few interns--wondering what their future is going to be in the midst of a global economic crisis that has accelerated a steady decline in newsprint. But there is a way out. It's painful, and there is no guarantee that newspapers will return to their former glory, but it's so crazy, it just might create a few jobs.

Step One: Fill in the war chest at the Freedom Forum. According to their 2007-08 report, the nonpartisan center focused on First Amendment issues, and media education projects received over $43 million in private giving in 2007--a 76 percent decrease and a drop in the bucket compared to the 30 percent each they received from domestic equity and hedge funds. That number has probably declined since the recession--nowhere in Econ 101 does it say that hedge funds are recession proof--meaning that the $1.1 billion in assets they enjoyed two years ago are kaput, made redundant, you get the idea. If the industry can get over its pride and hit up financiers for funding for the center, then perhaps the Freedom Forum can use the money for private grants to fund small newspapers. Just a thought.

Step Two: Take to the airwaves. Since newspapers started folding in 2008, the public perception has been that newspapers are dying--and taking the profession along with them. While it's true that interest in newsprint is waning, journalism is far from dead. Everyone from the New York Times to Rolling Stone magazine are going online--they're just not charging anyone for access to their articles. That needs to change. But first the public must be softened up--to use military jargon--and made known of the new changes. An advertising campaign on TV and radio will do the job just fine. It's expensive, no doubt, but if the New York Times buys TV slots for their ailing newspaper, the industry can buy ad slots to promote the idea of subscription-based news sites.

Step Three:
Invest in community newspapers. Once upon a time, small, independent newspapers and newsletters flourished in urban and rural locales. Many, such as I. F. Stone's I.F. Stone's Weekly, were privately funded--mostly through donations. These were the alternative presses of their day. It was only in the 1990s, as deregulation in print and cable made the environment more competitive, that organs such as the Village Voice abandoned subscription models in favor of ads. As big newspapers flounder and two paper towns become one--or more often, no paper towns--it is high time that the industry reinvest in these small time operations, through grants, if need be (see Step One). Just because they aren't household names doesn't mean they aren't good news agencies--look at the Brooklyn Daily News Web site sometime.

Step Four: Invest in our future--invest in community colleges and correspondence centers. As liberal arts majors such as journalism and communications continue to slag behind "well paying" professions like chemistry, finance and education, the profession needs to do more to get out beyond the ivory tower and recruit from the vast unwashed of our community colleges and correspondence centers. Though they might not have the same pedigree as a student from Chapel Hill or UCLA, these potential interns have something the J-school kids don't: real life experience. Many of them come from military backgrounds and law enforcement backgrounds--giving them added insight on topics like wiretapping, drug busts and a whole host of contemporary topics. Plus, you don't have to invest in a four-year education to make someone a reporter. This, by the way is how I started as an intern: I simply just waltzed into the office one day and asked if the staff at the community college I was attending needed any extra help. That was six years ago. Anyway, isn't this how Carl Bernstein got his start? And look where he's at right now.

So there you have it, my four-point plan for saving the Fourth Estate. It doesn't solve all of the industry's problems. But it sure does go a long way--and keeps the government out of the process at the same time.

Source: thecelebritycafe.com

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

Newspapers continue fight to beat the crunch

THE TV news channels and national media continue to be awash with depressing tales of mass-scale redundancies, recessions and a global credit crisis.
But in a bid to fight back, more local and regional papers are continuing to battle for their own communities and bolster business on their doorstep.
HoldtheFrontPage has reported on several campaigns across the UK press in recent weeks and here are a few more.
Newsquest daily The Press is running York Means Business and making a big deal of those local companies which are bucking the downward trend.
Recent good news story for the East and North Yorkshire area include the creation of new packing factory worth 100 jobs, HSBC's £300m proposal to build a new data centre creating 2,000 construction jobs, the expansion of the University of York and 50 new posts at a growing local law firm.
The Press says it will do everything it can to promote the York area as a centre of business excellence and also help unemployed people find fresh employment.
And Prime Minister Gordon Brown wrote an exclusive first-person piece for The Press about his support for the campaign.
Not content with helping Southampton's unemployed get back to work, the Southern Daily Echo has now launched Buy Local, Shop Local.
As the name suggests, the Echo wants Hampshire shoppers to stay local and support butchers, greengrocers and local cafes and restaurants.
To launch the campaign, Echo reporters and staff took to streets with campaign posters for local business to display in their shop windows.
Buy Local, Shop Local follows on from the Echo's Sell Yourself campaign which it launched in January.
The paper offered unemployed people the chance to show off their skills for free in a special in-paper supplement, in the hope local firms would offer them an interview.
The independently-owned Henley Standard has been garnering support from north of the border for its 'Think Local' campaign launched earlier this month.
After featuring on the BBC Breakfast news programme, the Standard was contacted by Strathaven Echo editor Bill Howat who said he would launch his own campaign after his after seeing the piece on TV.
The Standard's campaign is highlight local businesses, groups and individuals going out of their way to help other members of the community.
The Southport Visiter has joined forces with other local media to promote 'I Love Southport' – a campaign run by Southport Business Enterprise, a body responsible for maintaining the town centre.
The campaign is being run in conjunction with the Visiter's own 'Shop Local' initiative which it launched before Christmas to encourage people to shop in the Merseyside town.
I Love Southport is aimed specifically at boosting the resort's retail and hospitality trade and, as part of the campaign, a loyalty scheme has been set up with local businesses.
The lucky winner will receive £1,000 in cash just for using local shops regularly while the Visiter and other newspapers will be running competitions to win short breaks and shopping experiences in the town.

Source: HoldtheFrontPage.co.uk